The Financial Markets Law Committee (FMLC)—an independent body established by the Bank of England to identify issues of legal uncertainty that may affect the operation of financial markets—has published a new report, “Private Law Issues in AI.” The report, which was prepared by an FMLC Working Group including Robert Maddox, Partner in Debevoise & Plimpton’s Data Strategy & Security Group, interrogates whether existing private-law frameworks are equipped to handle AI-driven decision-making, and whether new doctrines or legal actors are required. Key issues include:

  1. Whether an AI system should be regarded as a tool (with human attribution) or an agent (with its own legal personality).
  2. How traditional contract, tort and liability doctrines apply when AI is used in financial transactions or trading.
  3. The readiness of English common law to absorb AI-related disputes without wholesale legislative intervention.
  4. Areas of continuing uncertainty, especially around data and intellectual-property regimes, and the adequacy of private-law protections in consumer/retail settings.

You can view the full report here.

* * *

To subscribe to the Data Blog, please click here.

Author

Robert Maddox is a partner in Debevoise & Plimpton LLP’s Data Strategy & Security practice, based in London. In 2021 he was named to Global Data Review’s “40 Under 40” and is described as “a rising star” in cyber law by The Legal 500 US (2022). His practice focuses on cybersecurity incident preparation and response, internal investigations and regulatory defence. Mr. Maddox also advises on data strategy and compliance in the context of emerging technologies, including AI, and operational resilience matters. He can be reached at rmaddox@debevoise.com.